Sato logo

The ‘Joker’ within us all

The Joker

Brazilian psychologist and psychotherapist, Flavio Cordeiro shares his thoughts after watching the film: Joker…

I watched Joker this weekend. It had been a long time since I came out of such a troubled movie. I believe this is one of the main functions of art: to disturb, to wake us up. The mechanism of the nightmares is more or less the same. Nightmares wake us up with an issue that needs to be addressed, or it will continue to haunt us all night long. Art, sometimes with beauty and emotion, bothers us for the same reason: it presents us with an indigestible subject that, as a society, we need to deal with. Joker is certainly indigestible.

Joker does not speak of a madman; It speaks of the process of madness that an insane society is capable of producing through the daily massacre it imposes on its most fragile members. Therefore, it speaks of all of us. Interestingly, on Saturday morning, before deciding to buy tickets for the movie, I re-read, somewhat haphazardly, “The Politics of Experience,” by Ronald Laing, a Scottish psychiatrist who wrote: 


 “In Britain at the moment there are about 60,000 men and women in mental health institutions. A child born in Britain today has ten times more opportunities to join a mental health institution than a university. This can be considered a sign that we are driving our children crazy far more effectively than we are raising them well. Maybe it’s our own way of educating them that drives them crazy.” (Laing 1967)


As I watched the Joker dance at the movie, those words hammered in my head, and I found myself wondering: How many Joker’s were built in these five decades that separate Laing’s writings from today?


While medicine and science continue to pursue a supposed organic origin for madness, Laing confronts us with an important question: How is madness a social product? Neglect, contempt, abuse, humiliation, endemic poverty, continuous exposure to violence; These are all social aspects involved in the process of going mad. They are all Gotham City products.


Jung, who was a psychiatrist at the largest psychiatric hospital in Switzerland at a time when the psychiatrist lived with his family at the hospital, says that if we take the trouble to listen carefully and attentively to that mentally ill person, the speech that seems absurd, suddenly acquires a meaning. In discovering meaning in the meaningless, there is a more human approach to that person who suffers from the same human problems as us, and, according to Jung, “he is nowhere near a disordered brain machine,” so he goes on: “We come to recognize in madness just an unusual reaction to emotional problems that belong to all of us. ”


What is inferred from Jung’s view is that there is a Joker far nearer to us than we suppose or would like to admit, simply because, being human, we are all exposed to the potentially maddening environment of the Gotham Cities we have created. I am not referring to the character’s outbursts of violence in the movie, but rather to the fact that the overwhelming social reality is capable of making life so unbearable as to undermine the psychological integrity of the individual.


The film shows an individual who violently retaliates with the same violence and humiliation he repeatedly suffers. But in real life, the mad almost never fight back, they get sick; their delirium is their way of dealing with the absurdity of Gotham City’s unspoiled scenery. On the contrary, it is the so-called “normal” people who violate the most and who endorse institutionalized violence.


Argentine psychiatrist Alfredo Moffatt says that in 30 years of work in therapeutic workshops with schizophrenic patients, he has never witnessed an episode of violence. He says: “fools are good people, they are peaceful,” the same cannot be said of “normal.” On the so-called “normal”, I return to the word of Ronald Laing: “The ‘normally alienated’ person, because he acts more or less like the others, it is considered healthy because society values the normal man highly. Normal men have killed perhaps 100,000,000 of their normal counterparts in the last fifty years. ”


It is not a matter of glorifying madness, which is one of the most serious conditions of human suffering, but of reflecting about the so called “normality” concept, as Gotham City and its “normal” citizens produce ‘Joker’s’. Arthur Fleck’s agonizing transformation into the Joker reminded me of an old phrase by Indian thinker Jiddu Krishnamurti: “It is not a sign of health to be well adapted to a sick society.”

While the Joker dances, Gotham City goes crazy.

Testimonials

The Counselling provision at our school is now excellent. This is due to Chloe’s understanding of the needs of pupils, parents and the school as an organization. I would whole-heartedly recommend ‘Child in Time’ to head-teachers considering their own counselling provision.

Head-teacher of Woolmore School, Tower Hamlets

Parent Consultation: They have become much better at expressing their feelings and opening up to me and their siblings.

Parent, 2023

School Counselling: My son has completely turned around and is simply wonderful at the moment. He is back to his normal self at home, being very happy, caring and kind. He is especial kind and caring with his sister and just the best brother ever now. As a family, we are happy and content.

Parent, 2023

It is quality time well spent not letting pupils leave with negative patterns that make them vulnerable beyond school. One of the best decisions I have made.

Head-teacher of St Saviour’s School, Tower Hamlets

You have helped me build a barrier of protection against pain and I can’t thank you enough for that…I have never felt so emotionally strong.

Student, aged 15

Child in Time is a tremendous resource for head-teachers. It’s a consultancy that offers a short-cut to setting up a counselling service in your school with highly trained, qualified practitioners. Child in Time brings peace of mind to staff, knowing that the most vulnerable students are in safe hands.

Tereza Nogueira, Child and Adolescent Psychotherapist and Senior supervisor UKCP

This intervention has had an enormous, positive impact for us all and we sincerely hope that other families benefit from the same programme…his positive behaviour is having a really good impact on all elements of his school life.

Parent of child, age 8

I am glad I am coming to see you every Thursday because I used to hold all these things in my head and that was hard.

Girl, age 10

We are very happy with the counselling service we are receiving and in particular ‘our therapist’s’ flexible and accommodating nature. Parents are very pleased, both the target children’s parents and the consultation one’s too.

SENCO, Rhodes Avenue School, Haringey

She is an outstanding therapist who has made a real difference to the lives of pupils in our school. ‘Our therapist’ possesses excellent skills in connecting with others, creating a safe space for staff, parents and pupils to discuss a range of issues. Her expertise, compassion, and dedication are truly commendable and we have really benefited from her thorough understanding of child development and psychology.

Deputy Head, Highgate Pre-Prep

I want to say thank you. I found these sessions very very helpful. I could talk about anything with you. I remember our first one, when I was so worried that everything was my fault. I can now see things more clearly.

student, age 11